More
HR Insights
Industry Insights
Friddy Hoegener
19 November 2026
Contingency search fits professional and manager roles where you want help without paying anything up front. Retained search fits director, VP, C-suite and confidential hires that need dedicated research and outreach. Exclusive contingency sits in between.
The right choice depends on how senior the role is and how hard it is to fill. It also depends on how fast you need someone and how much of the search you want one firm to own.
In a contingency search, you pay the recruiting firm only if you hire a candidate it presents. You don't pay anything to start the search.
You can give the same role to more than one firm. Your own team can keep posting the job and reviewing applicants at the same time. The firm that presents the person you hire earns the fee.
Contingency works well for professional and manager roles with a healthy pool of candidates. Examples include buyers, logistics coordinators, production planners and warehouse supervisors. It also suits companies that can't approve a recruiting cost before a candidate accepts an offer.
Because you can work with several sources at once, ask each firm how it will search for your role and how often it will update you.
In an exclusive contingency search, you work with one firm for an agreed period, and you still pay only if you hire. At SCOPE, that window is 30 days. During that time, SCOPE is your only outside recruiting firm, and your own team can keep recruiting and posting the role.
Because the firm knows the search is its own during that window, it can put dedicated time into the role. That time goes to direct outreach to passive candidates, people who are employed and not applying to jobs. You get one recruiting partner who runs the whole search and reports back to you.
Exclusive contingency fits specialized and hard-to-fill roles below the executive level. Examples include an S&OP manager, a demand planner with Kinaxis experience, a category manager for a technical spend area or a plant manager for a single site.
In a retained search, you pay part of the fee up front to start the search, and the rest at agreed points along the way. You work with one firm for the whole search.
The up-front payment pays for the search work itself. That work usually includes a detailed role profile, research into where the right people work today, outreach to passive candidates and regular progress updates. Many retained agreements split the fee into stages, such as one payment at the start, one when the shortlist is presented and the last one at the hire. The exact stages vary by firm, so read them in the agreement.
Retained search fits director, VP and C-suite roles. It also fits confidential searches, such as replacing a leader before the change is announced. For these roles, the right candidates are often a small group of people who are already succeeding somewhere else. Reaching them takes research time, careful outreach and several conversations.
Contingency
Exclusive contingency
Retained
Who you work with
One or more firms, plus your own team
One firm for an agreed period (30 days at SCOPE)
One firm for the whole search
When you pay
Only if you hire a candidate the firm presents
Part up front, the rest at agreed points
Typical roles
Professional and manager roles
Specialized and hard-to-fill roles
Director, VP, C-suite and confidential roles
What you get
Candidates from the firm's search, alongside your other sources
A dedicated recruiter and direct outreach to passive candidates
Research, a shortlist, regular updates and a dedicated search team
Start with four questions about the role.
For a buyer, analyst or supervisor, contingency is often enough. For a manager with a niche skill set, exclusive contingency gives the search more focus. For a director, VP or C-suite leader, retained search gives you dedicated research and outreach.
Some roles have a large pool of qualified candidates. Others need a rare combination, such as hands-on SAP S/4HANA conversion experience plus plant leadership. The smaller the pool, the more the search depends on direct outreach. That's where a dedicated search helps.
If you're replacing someone who doesn't know yet, or building a new function before you announce it, you need one firm that controls every conversation. That points to exclusive or retained search.
With contingency, your team still screens, compares and coordinates candidates from several sources. With exclusive or retained search, one firm runs the process from the intake call to the offer.
For example, a distribution center in North Alabama needed a WMS Transformation Lead with hands-on Manhattan WMS implementation and warehouse leadership experience. The client had reviewed online applications for months. We searched nationally, reached passive candidates who had both skill sets, and filled the role in six weeks.
Senior hires carry the most weight for your operation. SHRM research puts the total replacement cost of a bad hire at 50% to 200% of the employee's salary, depending on seniority. In our experience, a leadership hire also affects projects, supplier relationships and the team the new leader inherits. So for senior roles, choose the search type for the depth of search the role needs, then compare cost. Our guide to why vacant supply chain roles cost more than recruiting fees walks through the cost of an open role.
Every search type works better when your team is ready before the search starts.
Time for the intake call. Every SCOPE search starts with an intake call. We ask about the must-haves, what the person will do day to day and what success in the role looks like. We also give salary guidance, so the offer matches the market before candidates enter the process.
Exclusivity. With exclusive contingency and retained search, you agree to work with one firm for the agreed period. Agree up front how your internal recruiter and the firm will split the work, so candidates don't hear from two people about the same role.
Fast feedback. In our experience, strong candidates are often talking to more than one company. We recommend a 48-hour feedback window after each interview, so candidates hear back quickly and the search keeps moving.
A clear decision team. Decide who interviews, who makes the final call and what each person is evaluating. A shared scorecard keeps everyone judging candidates on the same criteria. Read more about how long a supply chain search should take.
Read the agreement closely, whichever search type you choose. Ask the firm these questions:
What is the fee based on? Ask whether the percentage applies to base salary only, or also to bonus and sign-on pay.
When is the fee paid? For retained search, ask what each payment covers and when it's due.
How long is the exclusive period, and how does it end? Ask what happens if the search isn't producing candidates partway through.
How long can the firm claim a fee for candidates it introduced? If you hire one of those candidates later, for this role or another one, a fee may still apply.
What is the replacement guarantee? Ask how long it lasts, what it covers and what conditions apply.
Who pays the fee? The employer pays. Candidates shouldn't pay a recruiter to be considered for a job.
SCOPE offers all three search types for supply chain, procurement, logistics, warehouse, operations and manufacturing, and executive roles. These are our standard fees:
Search type
SCOPE standard fee (of first-year base salary)
25%
Exclusive contingency (30 days)
20%
18%
SCOPE discounts its retained searches. One-third of the expected fee is paid up front as a retainer when the search starts, and the rest when the new hire starts. The retainer isn't refundable, but you can move it to another SCOPE search, for example if you fill the role with an internal candidate.
These are SCOPE's standard fees. Other firms set their own rates, payment schedules and terms, so ask for the full agreement in writing before the search starts. Every SCOPE search, whichever type you choose, comes with a 90-day replacement guarantee. If you're hiring at a manufacturing, engineering or supply chain company and want to talk through which search type and fee fit your role, contact us.
Every SCOPE recruiter has worked in supply chain. In our searches, 91% of placements are passive candidates. For senior roles, see our executive recruiters page, and for more on how search firms work, read what a supply chain headhunter does.
With contingency and exclusive contingency search, you pay only if you hire a candidate the firm presents. With retained search, you pay an agreed part of the fee up front to start the search.
Retained search is most common for director, VP and C-suite roles. It also fits confidential searches and specialized roles where a dedicated search team and market research are worth the up-front commitment.
It depends on the role, the location and how many qualified people are available. In our experience, finding the right candidate typically takes about two weeks, and the full hiring process takes about six weeks. Senior and specialized searches can take longer.
Yes. With contingency search, your internal recruiter can keep sourcing while an outside firm searches. With exclusive or retained search, agree up front on how your recruiter and the firm will split the work.
Talent mapping is research into where the people who could fill your role work today. It's a common part of retained search. Read our guide to talent mapping for supply chain roles.
If you're hiring a supply chain, procurement, logistics or operations leader, our supply chain recruiters can help you choose the search type that fits the role. If you're exploring your next career move, contact us to talk with our team.
Complete the form below to start your search for top-tier talent.